|
Book Review
The First Five Pages by Noah Lukeman
Review by Janis Wildy
If you're like most writers, the first few pages are the hardest to write. Noah Lukeman,
author of The First Five Pages, a Writer's Guide to Staying Out of the Rejection Pile,
agrees: you have at best five pages in which to hook or lose a new reader.
As an agent, Lukeman works from a position of rejection. Facing an enormous pile of
submissions, he looks for reasons to reject a manuscript, rather than accept it.
In this book, Lukeman helps you make sure your manuscript is one he cannot pass up.
Part one of the book addresses the look of the manuscript as well as the use and abuse of
adverbs, adjectives, style and comparison. Each chapter ends with a helpful summary and
list of exercises. While his own tone can seem critical and even elitist, each chapter
opens with an inspiring quote to help you realize that other writers have faced these same
problems.
Part two addresses dialogue, which if done poorly, will cause Lukeman to reject a book.
Visually, he looks for too many or too little identifiers, as well as dialogue that is
commonplace or too sparse. His exercises encourage you to look for the original intent
of the scene as a way to elevate the interactions between characters.
Lukeman takes part three of his book to address broader issues that might occur during
the first fifty pages, like character development and use of description. This section
can be used whether you've got those first five pages nailed or not. Some of his peeves
(like using several names for one character) are blessedly easy to fix. Some are fun to
contemplate, like coming up with hooks for your opening sentences. But others are much
more difficult like questioning whether every sentence supports the tone and focus of the
novel. It's not until the end of the book that Lukeman discusses pacing and progression.
If the writing is good enough, then he'll take a look at the synopsis and the shape of
the story.
This isn't a book to read during the writing process, but afterwards when you want to
look at your manuscript as if an agent or editor is seeing it for the first time.
Lukeman is that picky, meticulous person who you want to scrutinize your manuscript because
you know he will improve your writing, even though you may have to endure a few painful
changes along the way. When your novel is sitting pretty in that monstrous stack of
submissions, you'll be glad you did.
Janis Wildy is a writer and editor living in Seattle. She is currently revising her novel, Backstage Pass.
|